Encoding

Synopsis

While encoding in the Cosmos SDK used to be mainly handled by go-amino codec, the Cosmos SDK is moving towards using gogoprotobuf for both state and client-side encoding.

note

Pre-requisite Readings

• Anatomy of a Cosmos SDK application

Encoding

The Cosmos SDK utilizes two binary wire encoding protocols, Amino which is an object encoding specification and Protocol Buffers, a subset of Proto3 with an extension for interface support. See the Proto3 spec for more information on Proto3, which Amino is largely compatible with (but not with Proto2).

Due to Amino having significant performance drawbacks, being reflection-based, and not having any meaningful cross-language/client support, Protocol Buffers, specifically gogoprotobuf, is being used in place of Amino. Note, this process of using Protocol Buffers over Amino is still an ongoing process.

Binary wire encoding of types in the Cosmos SDK can be broken down into two main categories, client encoding and store encoding. Client encoding mainly revolves around transaction processing and signing, whereas store encoding revolves around types used in state-machine transitions and what is ultimately stored in the Merkle tree.

For store encoding, protobuf definitions can exist for any type and will typically have an Amino-based "intermediary" type. Specifically, the protobuf-based type definition is used for serialization and persistence, whereas the Amino-based type is used for business logic in the state-machine where they may convert back-n-forth. Note, the Amino-based types may slowly be phased-out in the future, so developers should take note to use the protobuf message definitions where possible.

In the codec package, there exists two core interfaces, BinaryCodec and JSONCodec, where the former encapsulates the current Amino interface except it operates on types implementing the latter instead of generic interface{} types.

In addition, there exists two implementations of Codec. The first being AminoCodec, where both binary and JSON serialization is handled via Amino. The second being ProtoCodec, where both binary and JSON serialization is handled via Protobuf.

This means that modules may use Amino or Protobuf encoding, but the types must implement ProtoMarshaler. If modules wish to avoid implementing this interface for their types, they may use an Amino codec directly.

Amino

Every module uses an Amino codec to serialize types and interfaces. This codec typically has types and interfaces registered in that module's domain only (e.g. messages), but there are exceptions like x/gov. Each module exposes a RegisterLegacyAminoCodec function that allows a user to provide a codec and have all the types registered. An application will call this method for each necessary module.

Where there is no protobuf-based type definition for a module (see below), Amino is used to encode and decode raw wire bytes to the concrete type or interface:

bz := keeper.cdc.MustMarshal(typeOrInterface)
keeper.cdc.MustUnmarshal(bz, &typeOrInterface)

Note, there are length-prefixed variants of the above functionality and this is typically used for when the data needs to be streamed or grouped together (e.g. ResponseDeliverTx.Data)

Authz authorizations and Gov/Group proposals

Since authz's MsgExec and MsgGrant message types, as well as gov's and group's MsgSubmitProposal, can contain different messages instances, it is important that developers add the following code inside the init method of their module's codec.go file:

import (
  authzcodec "github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/x/authz/codec"
  govcodec "github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/x/gov/codec"
  groupcodec "github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/x/group/codec"
)

init() {
    // Register all Amino interfaces and concrete types on the authz and gov Amino codec so that this can later be
    // used to properly serialize MsgGrant, MsgExec and MsgSubmitProposal instances
    RegisterLegacyAminoCodec(authzcodec.Amino)
    RegisterLegacyAminoCodec(govcodec.Amino)
    RegisterLegacyAminoCodec(groupcodec.Amino)
}

This will allow the x/authz module to properly serialize and de-serializes MsgExec instances using Amino, which is required when signing this kind of messages using a Ledger.

Gogoproto

Modules are encouraged to utilize Protobuf encoding for their respective types. In the Cosmos SDK, we use the Gogoproto specific implementation of the Protobuf spec that offers speed and DX improvements compared to the official Google protobuf implementation.

Guidelines for protobuf message definitions

In addition to following official Protocol Buffer guidelines, we recommend using these annotations in .proto files when dealing with interfaces:

• use cosmos_proto.accepts_interface to annote Any fields that accept interfaces
  • pass the same fully qualified name as protoName to InterfaceRegistry.RegisterInterface
  • example: (cosmos_proto.accepts_interface) = "cosmos.gov.v1beta1.Content" (and not just Content)
• annotate interface implementations with cosmos_proto.implements_interface
  • pass the same fully qualified name as protoName to InterfaceRegistry.RegisterInterface
  • example: (cosmos_proto.implements_interface) = "cosmos.authz.v1beta1.Authorization" (and not just Authorization)

Code generators can then match the accepts_interface and implements_interface annotations to know whether some Protobuf messages are allowed to be packed in a given Any field or not.

Transaction Encoding

Another important use of Protobuf is the encoding and decoding of transactions. Transactions are defined by the application or the Cosmos SDK but are then passed to the underlying consensus engine to be relayed to other peers. Since the underlying consensus engine is agnostic to the application, the consensus engine accepts only transactions in the form of raw bytes.

• The TxEncoder object performs the encoding.
• The TxDecoder object performs the decoding.

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/types/tx_msg.go#L76-L80

A standard implementation of both these objects can be found in the auth/tx module:

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/x/auth/tx/decoder.go

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/x/auth/tx/encoder.go

See ADR-020 for details of how a transaction is encoded.

Interface Encoding and Usage of Any

The Protobuf DSL is strongly typed, which can make inserting variable-typed fields difficult. Imagine we want to create a Profile protobuf message that serves as a wrapper over an account:

message Profile {
  // account is the account associated to a profile.
  cosmos.auth.v1beta1.BaseAccount account = 1;
  // bio is a short description of the account.
  string bio = 4;
}

In this Profile example, we hardcoded account as a BaseAccount. However, there are several other types of user accounts related to vesting, such as BaseVestingAccount or ContinuousVestingAccount. All of these accounts are different, but they all implement the AccountI interface. How would you create a Profile that allows all these types of accounts with an account field that accepts an AccountI interface?

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/x/auth/types/account.go#L307-L330

In ADR-019, it has been decided to use Anys to encode interfaces in protobuf. An Any contains an arbitrary serialized message as bytes, along with a URL that acts as a globally unique identifier for and resolves to that message's type. This strategy allows us to pack arbitrary Go types inside protobuf messages. Our new Profile then looks like:

message Profile {
  // account is the account associated to a profile.
  google.protobuf.Any account = 1 [
    (cosmos_proto.accepts_interface) = "cosmos.auth.v1beta1.AccountI"; // Asserts that this field only accepts Go types implementing `AccountI`. It is purely informational for now.
  ];
  // bio is a short description of the account.
  string bio = 4;
}

To add an account inside a profile, we need to "pack" it inside an Any first, using codectypes.NewAnyWithValue:

var myAccount AccountI
myAccount = ... // Can be a BaseAccount, a ContinuousVestingAccount or any struct implementing `AccountI`

// Pack the account into an Any
accAny, err := codectypes.NewAnyWithValue(myAccount)
if err != nil {
  return nil, err
}

// Create a new Profile with the any.
profile := Profile {
  Account: accAny,
  Bio: "some bio",
}

// We can then marshal the profile as usual.
bz, err := cdc.Marshal(profile)
jsonBz, err := cdc.MarshalJSON(profile)

To summarize, to encode an interface, you must 1/ pack the interface into an Any and 2/ marshal the Any. For convenience, the Cosmos SDK provides a MarshalInterface method to bundle these two steps. Have a look at a real-life example in the x/auth module.

The reverse operation of retrieving the concrete Go type from inside an Any, called "unpacking", is done with the GetCachedValue() on Any.

profileBz := ... // The proto-encoded bytes of a Profile, e.g. retrieved through gRPC.
var myProfile Profile
// Unmarshal the bytes into the myProfile struct.
err := cdc.Unmarshal(profilebz, &myProfile)

// Let's see the types of the Account field.
fmt.Printf("%T\n", myProfile.Account)                  // Prints "Any"
fmt.Printf("%T\n", myProfile.Account.GetCachedValue()) // Prints "BaseAccount", "ContinuousVestingAccount" or whatever was initially packed in the Any.

// Get the address of the accountt.
accAddr := myProfile.Account.GetCachedValue().(AccountI).GetAddress()

It is important to note that for GetCachedValue() to work, Profile (and any other structs embedding Profile) must implement the UnpackInterfaces method:

func (p *Profile) UnpackInterfaces(unpacker codectypes.AnyUnpacker) error {
  if p.Account != nil {
    var account AccountI
    return unpacker.UnpackAny(p.Account, &account)
  }

  return nil
}

The UnpackInterfaces gets called recursively on all structs implementing this method, to allow all Anys to have their GetCachedValue() correctly populated.

For more information about interface encoding, and especially on UnpackInterfaces and how the Any's type_url gets resolved using the InterfaceRegistry, please refer to ADR-019.

Any Encoding in the Cosmos SDK

The above Profile example is a fictive example used for educational purposes. In the Cosmos SDK, we use Any encoding in several places (non-exhaustive list):

• the cryptotypes.PubKey interface for encoding different types of public keys,
• the sdk.Msg interface for encoding different Msgs in a transaction,
• the AccountI interface for encodinig different types of accounts (similar to the above example) in the x/auth query responses,
• the Evidencei interface for encoding different types of evidences in the x/evidence module,
• the AuthorizationI interface for encoding different types of x/authz authorizations,
• the Validator struct that contains information about a validator.

A real-life example of encoding the pubkey as Any inside the Validator struct in x/staking is shown in the following example:

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/x/staking/types/validator.go#L41-L64

Any's TypeURL

When packing a protobuf message inside an Any, the message's type is uniquely defined by its type URL, which is the message's fully qualified name prefixed by a / (slash) character. In some implementations of Any, like the gogoproto one, there's generally a resolvable prefix, e.g. type.googleapis.com. However, in the Cosmos SDK, we made the decision to not include such prefix, to have shorter type URLs. The Cosmos SDK's own Any implementation can be found in github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/codec/types.

The Cosmos SDK is also switching away from gogoproto to the official google.golang.org/protobuf (known as the Protobuf API v2). Its default Any implementation also contains the type.googleapis.com prefix. To maintain compatibility with the SDK, the following methods from "google.golang.org/protobuf/types/known/anypb" should not be used:

• anypb.New
• anypb.MarshalFrom
• anypb.Any#MarshalFrom

Instead, the Cosmos SDK provides helper functions in "github.com/cosmos/cosmos-proto/anyutil", which create an official anypb.Any without inserting the prefixes:

• anyutil.New
• anyutil.MarshalFrom

For example, to pack a sdk.Msg called internalMsg, use:

import (
-   "google.golang.org/protobuf/types/known/anypb"
+   "github.com/cosmos/cosmos-proto/anyutil"
)

- anyMsg, err := anypb.New(internalMsg.Message().Interface())
+ anyMsg, err := anyutil.New(internalMsg.Message().Interface())

- fmt.Println(anyMsg.TypeURL) // type.googleapis.com/cosmos.bank.v1beta1.MsgSend
+ fmt.Println(anyMsg.TypeURL) // /cosmos.bank.v1beta1.MsgSend

FAQ

How to create modules using protobuf encoding

Defining module types

Protobuf types can be defined to encode:

• state
• Msgs
• Query services
• genesis

Naming and conventions

We encourage developers to follow industry guidelines: Protocol Buffers style guide and Buf, see more details in ADR 023

How to update modules to protobuf encoding

If modules do not contain any interfaces (e.g. Account or Content), then they may simply migrate any existing types that are encoded and persisted via their concrete Amino codec to Protobuf (see 1. for further guidelines) and accept a Marshaler as the codec which is implemented via the ProtoCodec without any further customization.

However, if a module type composes an interface, it must wrap it in the sdk.Any (from /types package) type. To do that, a module-level .proto file must use google.protobuf.Any for respective message type interface types.

For example, in the x/evidence module defines an Evidence interface, which is used by the MsgSubmitEvidence. The structure definition must use sdk.Any to wrap the evidence file. In the proto file we define it as follows:

// proto/cosmos/evidence/v1beta1/tx.proto

message MsgSubmitEvidence {
  string              submitter = 1;
  google.protobuf.Any evidence  = 2 [(cosmos_proto.accepts_interface) = "cosmos.evidence.v1beta1.Evidence"];
}

The Cosmos SDK codec.Codec interface provides support methods MarshalInterface and UnmarshalInterface to easy encoding of state to Any.

Module should register interfaces using InterfaceRegistry which provides a mechanism for registering interfaces: RegisterInterface(protoName string, iface interface{}, impls ...proto.Message) and implementations: RegisterImplementations(iface interface{}, impls ...proto.Message) that can be safely unpacked from Any, similarly to type registration with Amino:

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/codec/types/interface_registry.go#L24-L57

In addition, an UnpackInterfaces phase should be introduced to deserialization to unpack interfaces before they're needed. Protobuf types that contain a protobuf Any either directly or via one of their members should implement the UnpackInterfacesMessage interface:

type UnpackInterfacesMessage interface {
  UnpackInterfaces(InterfaceUnpacker) error
}

Custom Stringer

Using option (gogoproto.goproto_stringer) = false; in a proto message definition leads to unexpected behaviour, like returning wrong output or having missing fields in the output. For that reason a proto Message's String() must not be customized, and the goproto_stringer option must be avoided.

A correct YAML output can be obtained through ProtoJSON, using the JSONToYAML function:

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/codec/yaml.go#L8-L20

For example:

https://github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/blob/v0.47.0-rc1/x/auth/types/account.go#L141-L151